![]() |
|
NEW FULL-RANGE DRIVERS FOR HORNS RECEIVED - Printable Version +- Chellos Keyboard Players Club (https://chellos-keyboard-players-club.com) +-- Forum: ARTICLES (https://chellos-keyboard-players-club.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1135) +--- Forum: ARTICLES (https://chellos-keyboard-players-club.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=6) +---- Forum: CHELLO`S ARTICLES (https://chellos-keyboard-players-club.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=94) +---- Thread: NEW FULL-RANGE DRIVERS FOR HORNS RECEIVED (/showthread.php?tid=22982) |
NEW FULL-RANGE DRIVERS FOR HORNS RECEIVED - Chello - 11-18-2026 NEW FULL-RANGE DRIVERS FOR HORNS RECEIVED Today, I received the new MeloDavid full-range drivers I had ordered for my horns. They arrived in very well-packaged boxes. A few things turned out to be different from the description: The size is 3.5" rather than 4". This measurement includes the surround; the diaphragm itself is 70 mm - just under 3". Furthermore, the weight is not 2.2 kg each, but about half that - which is still quite substantial for such a small driver. That’s fine, though; all other dimensions are correct. What matters is that the specified technical data is accurate and that the units are consistent with one another - something I will verify when I take measurements later this evening. I was immediately and very pleasantly surprised upon unboxing them; the craftsmanship is of the highest caliber - truly the best I have ever seen. The attached photo does not do them justice..! RE: NEW FULL-RANGE DRIVERS FOR HORNS RECEIVED - Chello - 11-18-2026 MeloDavid Measurements The impedance curves are very smooth (red line), with a slight hump at 1750 Hz and a declining impedance below 500 Hz—a characteristic that should yield a full-bodied and warm bass reproduction. The curve also shows that the response drops off sharply from 100 Hz downwards. They do not present a difficult load for the amplifier (blue line), as the curve is free of any problematic excursions, showing only a minor bump right at 1600 Hz. The nominal impedance is stated as 8 ohms, while my measurements show values ranging from 5.394 to 5.682 ohms; however, values slightly above 6 ohms are typical for units rated at 8 ohms. The specified F(s) is 68.5 Hz, whereas my measurements show 82.9 to 85.56 Hz—though these values will shift once the units are mounted in a baffle. The Q(ts) is specified as 0.300, while my measurements range from 0.2957 to 0.423—a result that can certainly be considered acceptable. All in all, the measured data are exceptionally consistent - I have tested many expensive SEAS drivers and other high-end units that do not exhibit such smooth measurements. What is always particularly interesting is the impedance curve, because this - more than anything else - provides an indication of the frequency response. In this case, it is extremely smooth - on par with the drivers I use in my other horn-loaded systems. Everything suggests that these 3" MeloDavid full-range drivers are state-of-the-art - both in terms of measurements and appearance. I’ll be starting the work of disassembling and modifying the baffles for the horns one of these days. UNIT 1 UNIT 2 UNIT 3 UNIT 4 UNIT 5 UNIT 6 RE: NEW FULL-RANGE DRIVERS FOR HORNS RECEIVED - Chello - 11-19-2026 MEASURES MORE LINEARLY AND BETTER THAN SEAS EXCEL Just for fun, I measured a SEAS Excel 6.5" woofer (I have 4 of them), which costs more than 10 times as much as the MeloDavid. The measured data are nearly identical, but the MeloDavid is slightly better. The SEAS extends about 20 Hz lower, but then again, this is a 6.5" woofer/midrange driver. It is honestly incredible that a 3" driver delivers nearly the same bass reproduction as a 6.5" unit - the latter costing more than 10 times as much. Furthermore, the build quality is the best I have ever seen, regardless of price. SEAS has always produced the world’s best drivers, which are used in the world’s best loudspeakers. MeloDavid will give SEAS some stiff competition.
|